Inference of Preference Heterogeneity from Choice Data
نویسنده
چکیده
Suppose that an analyst observes inconsistent choices from a decision maker. Can the analyst determine whether this inconsistency arises from choice error (imperfect maximization of a single preference) or from preference heterogeneity (deliberate maximization of multiple preferences)? I model choice data as generated from context-dependent preferences, where contexts vary across observations, and the decision maker errs with small probability in each observation. I show that (a) simultaneously minimizing the number of inferred preferences and the number of unexplained observations can exactly recover the correct number of preferences with high probability; (b) simultaneously minimizing the richness of the set of preferences and the number of unexplained observations can exactly recover the choice implications of the decision maker’s true preferences with high probability. These results illustrate that selection of simple models, appropriately defined, is a useful approach for recovery of stable features of preference.
منابع مشابه
Inference under Stability of Risk Preferences∗
We leverage the assumption that preferences are stable across contexts to partially identify and conduct inference on the parameters of a structural model of risky choice. Working with data on households’deductible choices across three lines of insurance coverage and a model that nests expected utility theory plus a range of non-expected utility models, we perform a revealed preference analysis...
متن کاملExperimental measurement of preferences in health care using best-worst scaling (BWS): theoretical and statistical issues.
For optimal solutions in health care, decision makers inevitably must evaluate trade-offs, which call for multi-attribute valuation methods. Researchers have proposed using best-worst scaling (BWS) methods which seek to extract information from respondents by asking them to identify the best and worst items in each choice set. While a companion paper describes the different types of BWS, applic...
متن کاملObserved and Unobserved Preference Heterogeneity In Brand Choice Models
In deciding what brand to buy consumers trade off between how valuable each brand is to them and its price. Scanner data based brand choice models that evaluate this trade off and allow for unobserved heterogeneity are a very popular topic. We extend this line of research by explicitly incorporating brand preferences rather than just utilizing brand specific constants and past purchase behavior...
متن کاملAccommodating for Taste and Variance Heterogeneity in Discrete Choice†
Understanding and accommodating heterogeneity in variance (also referred to as heteroscedasticity) and taste has become a major area of research within discrete choice analysis. Both scale and taste heterogeneity can be specified as continuous or discrete, the latter can be associated with socio economic characteristics (i.e. observed heterogeneity) or it can be derived probabilistically (i.e. ...
متن کاملDisentangling Preferences and Learning in Brand Choice Models
In recent years there has been a growing stream of literature in marketing and economics that models consumers as Bayesian learners. Such learning behavior is often embedded within a discrete choice framework which is then calibrated on scanner panel data. At the same time it is now accepted wisdom that disentangling preference heterogeneity and state dependence is critical in any attempt to un...
متن کامل